Welcome to Olde New York, a hidden gem nestled in State College, PA, that beautifully marries classic American cuisine with delightful German influences. This charming bar and grill, located at 2298 E College Ave, invites diners into a cozy setting that feels like stepping back in time, yet brims with contemporary flair.
As you step through the doors, you’re greeted by a warm atmosphere that is enhanced by friendly service and decor that celebrates nostalgia. The inviting interior is perfect for both a casual night out with friends or a cozy dinner with family. Enjoy a selection of hearty favorites that will leave you feeling satisfied and content.
The menu at Olde New York is a culinary adventure that prominently features beloved German dishes alongside classic American grill fare. Dive into their renowned Cheese Spätzle, a stunning dish that combines tender pasta with a rich, cheesy sauce, making it a must-try. For those craving comfort food, the Bavarian Schnitzel stands out, offering a delightful combination of flavors with ham, cheese, and BBQ sauce elevating this traditional favorite to new heights.
Don't miss the opportunity to savor their delectable Pierogies, which many guests rave about. As one customer noted, the pierogies are "absolutely delicious," setting the tone for a meal that is both hearty and comforting. If you're looking for something lighter, the salads are prepared with fresh, crisp mixed greens, ensuring that there's something for everyone.
For those with a sweet tooth, the Lemon Blueberry Cheesecake has garnered rave reviews, with one guest declaring it an "OMG" dessert that shouldn't be missed. Whether you pair your meal with one of their thoughtfully curated German beers or a cocktail from the full bar, Olde New York promises a dining experience that tantalizes the taste buds.
Olde New York isn’t just about the food; it's about the overall experience. Patrons have praised the establishment not only for its delightful cuisine but also for its welcoming vibe and attentive staff. As one happy visitor shared, the waitress's positive attitude and excellent service certainly made a lasting impression.
If you're in the State College area and looking for an authentic spot to enjoy some comfort food with a twist, Olde New York is the place to be. Offering a unique dining experience far from the typical chain restaurant, this bar and grill is a treasured destination for locals and visitors alike. Visit soon, and savor the warm embrace of this delightful retreat.
Your insights help other diners decide. We’ll keep your email private. Required fields are marked *
222 E Calder Way, State College, PA 16801, United States
Am Graben 10, 87600 Kaufbeuren, Germany
Level 2/605-609 George St, Sydney NSW 2000, Australia
1801 SW Wanamaker Rd, Topeka, KS 66604, United States
Av. Gov. Celso Ramos, 2700, Porto Belo - SC, 88210-000, Brazil
4691 Wyandotte St E, Windsor, ON N8Y 1H6, Canada
Discover new menus and trending dishes on Menustic.
Menustic helps you discover menus from restaurants, cafés, and bars around the world. Explore destinations, compare dishes and prices, and decide where to eat or drink — Fantastic Menus, One Click Away.
© 2026 Menustic. Built to help people discover menus and decide what to eat and drink.
Grisha L
21/11/2025
Been coming here for years, I came by last night for the first time in almost a decade, had to stop by. Had a great experience as always, they have a small but nice German menu and I love their Spätzle. They had a weekly menu item for Oktoberfest, was kind of cool, but watch out for the portion sizes! You won't be disappointed.
Dave Romanyshyn
29/10/2025
I was pleasantly surprised by this place. From the road it looks like it might just be some chain or knockoff of a chain. However, it was totally different once inside. The beer selection was much better than expected with some good German beers. The food was also delicious. May have some German dishes that are excellent. I will return.
Jeff Smith
27/10/2025
Cheese Spatzle was amazing. Bavarian Schnitzel was different with ham, cheese, and BBQ sauce.
2 Thumbz
09/10/2025
We drove 45-50 minutes here from the Altoona area and for the most part was not disappointed. Unfortunately my wife’s meal was a swing and a miss but the rest of our food was very good. The waitress was on top of everything and had a very positive attitude and polite. She was even nice enough to comp the meal. Pierogie appetizer was absolutely delicious and the Lemon Blueberry Cheesecake OMG!! The Bavarian Pretzel appetizer is a meal in itself!! Would more than likely come back again.
Dgg Ghjh Fghh
30/09/2025
Olde New York – Review Olde New York delivers classic American and German-inspired pub fare in a cozy, traditional setting. Favorites include schnitzel, pierogies, and hearty burgers, often paired with a good beer selection. The atmosphere is welcoming and nostalgic, with friendly service and generous portions. A solid spot for comfort food with a vintage vibe.
Lisa Desmarais
16/09/2025
Olde New York is an excellent place for a meal out! They also have a full bar, tempting desserts and appetizers to please every palate! They have the best beef stew I’ve ever had at a restaurant (it’s Ghoulash on the menu). The steaks are great! Bonus for serving mashed potatoes straight up, without garlic. Salads are fresh, with lots of mixed greens. The customer service is excellent, and the atmosphere is great too. It can get a bit loud, definitely not a place to go for a subdued dining experience. If you’re in State College and trying to experience some of the local flavors, it’s a must-try!
Sasha Miller
21/08/2025
Unique spot. I was totally apprehensive as soon as we noticed this restaurant was located in a strip mall but thank goodness we gave it a shot anyway. As soon as you walk through the door you are wrapped in a warm and welcoming interior with smiles to boot. The menu is a happy step away from what you find at your usual establishment. There are many specialties and tons of options I wouldn’t mind trying! We decided to go for two of the schnitzel options. No disappointment! Everything was delish! The portions were more than generous. Wait staff—very attentive and pleasant. In fact she was sweet enough to pitch in when we were having trouble taking a selfie. More than that she showed us where to get the best shot and snapped it herself! Would return anytime!